The Critique of Dr. Larry Crabb and Dr. Ron Hawkins

Two theorists, Dr. Crabb and Dr. Hawkins defend different theories more over the corresponding goal in mind when discussing integrating spirituality and custodytal science. The ultimate goal for all theorists should be to reach the need of the lymph gland. Dr. Crabb discusses the difference between the process of a laic direction and those of a Christian guidance. He explains that even though their ultimate goal is the same the avenue they polish off is different due to a different batch of rules. Dr Crabbs surmisal relies heavily on the Bible and Abraham Maslows undefiled needs hierarchy.Dr Crabb describes the difference in how people perceive their problems, some flummox ownership, and other may blame the milieu. According to Dr. Crabb, our re actions to our difficult life experiences take one of three forms guilt, resentment or anxiety (Crabb, 1977). In Dr. Crabbs book, Effective Biblical Counseling, he summarizes a three-level hash out program which stub be pe rformed by members of the church, use the concept that every Christian peck minister the word of God.Also read thisCritique of Stuff Is non SalvationThe offset printing level is about educating the members of the church members on the prefatory practices and principles of biblical script, strategies of counseling and the tools to use to accomplish the counseling. The second level the uses scripture to persuade the lymph gland to perceive the bit and solution christianly. By exploitation scripture to explain the situation and solution the lymph node make the affinity to their situation. The third level is establishing a character which displays godly behavior that conforms to the standards of the church.The counselor should represent Christian values and principles in their everyday life. Dr. Crabb also discusses his four-spot-spot approaches to integration of Christianity and psychology. The first approach and the most balance of Dr. Crabbs four approaches ar Spoiling the Egyptians (Crabb, 1977). In the teachings of this approach Dr. Crabb changes the direction of teaching out emplacement(a) from the traditional teaching that man has three parts. Dr. Crabb suggests that man has only cardinal parts somatogenic and personal, or clobber and non-material (p. 88).The physical posture be to the material side and the spirit and soul belonging to the immaterial side (p. 88). This approach also teaches that psychology is under Gods perfect, incompetent of mistakes, brilliant revelations. According to Dr. Crabb scripture is to have precedence over non-biblical flavor in a purposeful capacity. The second approach is Separate but equal. This viewpoint establishes that psychology and spirituality does not mix anymore than if a person needs a serious operation they do not go to the bible for direction, they go to the hospital.Scripture is used to care a person deal with their troubling emotions or teaching of lessons. For prototype inProverbs 423 sta tes, above all else, guard your affection, for it is the wellspring of life. The heart includes the mind and all that proceeds from it. Next we have the Tossed Salad approach which blends divinity and psychology. It gage be confusing because it does not blend in with secular concepts when suggesting Biblical truth. Last approach is the Nothing Buttery approach which disregards psychology all unitedly.This approach says that all that is needed is Christ. This is clearly seen in capital of Minnesotas commendation to Timothy from infancy you have known the blessed Scriptures, which are able to make you wise for salvation through doctrine in Christ Jesus. All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be thoroughly fit out for every good work 2 Timothy 315-17 (King crowd Version). He suggests that most patients are ego centered because they seek counseling in their desire to be happy.He n avigates away from the teachings that man is a tri-part creature and suggests that man has a dickens part division The material side and immaterial side (p. 88). He explains that the path to true gratification is to be similar Christ. He believes the goal of counseling is spiritual and psychological maturity and concern in fate people enter into great worship and affective life of service. Dr. Crabb explains in his book that Maturity involves two elements long range character growth and immediate obedience (p. 3). He feels that by using the seven stage model a counselor will be able to pick out where wrong belief was learned, shape up expression of emotions surround beliefs, support the client as they change their beliefs, helping the client decipher the true meaning of the word, securing a commitment from the client to act on these beliefs, build a invent with the client on what action needs to be taken with their new beliefs and help them identify their lack of sin related feels and the presence of spiritual feelings.Dr. Hawkins (2010) utilizes a bent grass of concentric circles to demonstrate the factors that make up an soul. He starts with the innermost self, which is the upshot self. He explains that a healthy psychological person has a beatified Spirit at the core, He adds more circles to show how the individuals personality in influenced. This is similar to Bronfenbrenners Ecological System Theory, which describes an individuals development within the context of the individuals environment. conflicting Dr Crabb, Dr. Hawkins emphasizes more on working with the client to build an intervention where the client will take ownership of the strategy and process of personal change. Dr Hawkins describes the first phase of a four phase model to extrapolate the actual problem. The client talks the counselor listens. Phase two, is paraphrasing and tracking what the client is sincerely saying. Phase three is setting up a plan of action involving the client so the client is engaged in ownership for this plan of action and responsibility for its outcome.In the final phase the counselor supports and fleets the client to take accountability in the process of change. Evaluation of Strengths and Weaknesses Both these theories are similar and the outcome will be the same but the action is different. In both theories the strength outweigh the negative because they are allow the client learn about themselves and how to partition their own problems. Both men rely on Gods guidance to lead in changing hurting humanity. Each model is well put together and easy to use. Dr. Crabbs theory is more detailed whereas Dr. Hawkins presented his model in a more condensed form. Dr. Crabb proposes the counselor guides the client to be godly like and use the scriptures from the Bible to help the client understand the situation in comparison of a parable in the Bible, the compare the solution to what can be done to fix the problem. Dr. Hawkins theory starts out with the core self and explains that a psychologically healthy person has the Holy Spirit at the core. As he adds circles to tailor the influences to the clients individual environment and life events explain the clients personality.The Counselor listens to the client and thusly paraphrase to make certain of the problem. The client is involved in the plans and goals of overcoming the situation. By doing this the client can take accountability and responsibility of the outcome. Personal grammatical construction and Application In reflection of both these theories, I agree that the client should be guided in understanding the problem and in using the biblical parables to build a comparison to the underline problem and the silk hat solution. As Christian children we are taught from the bible and use biblical verses to understand whats and whys of life.In using Dr. Crabbs theory we can break down what is going on in the advised mind and what is hidden in the unconscious mind. As counselors, we can breakdown the how the problem developed and what we can do to change the situation. We can guide the client into making these changes to better their lives. Dr Hawkins theory makes the client be liable for the outcome by using the demonstrating the concentric circles to demonstrate how the problem gave stimulate to using the clients environment and personality to change the situation and have a better outcome.I, personally was very interested in Dr, Crabbs four approaches of integrating Christianity and psychology, especially the Spoiling the Egyptians (Crabb, 1977). As he explained that in this approach Dr. Crabb that man has only two parts physical and personal, or material and non-material (p. 88). The physical side belonging to the material side and the spirit and soul belonging to the immaterial side (p. 88). When working with clients in a Christian Counseling scenario scripture is to have precedence over non-biblical opinion in a purposeful capaci ty.